Do you flip Tomahawk steak while smoking?

Imagine this: a bone-in, marbled-to-perfection Tomahawk steak, smoked until it’s bursting with flavor and boasting a mouthwatering crust. Sounds delicious, doesn’t it?

But here’s the burning question: should you flip that glorious steak while it’s smoking? Prepare to be surprised by the answer.

While some grill masters argue against flipping, there are those who swear by it. So where do you stand?

In this blog post, we’ll dive into the debate and explore the pros and cons of flipping a Tomahawk steak while it smokes. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurous experimenter, we’ve got you covered.

Let’s fire up those smokers and start cooking.

Do you flip Tomahawk steak while smoking-2


What is a Tomahawk Steak?

Prepare to be amazed by the unparalleled beauty and exquisite flavor of a Tomahawk steak. This bone-in ribeye is not only a treat for the senses but also a true work of culinary art. In this article, we will delve into the world of the Tomahawk steak, exploring its origins, preparation techniques, and expert tips for grilling perfection.

The Tomahawk Steak: A Cut Above the Rest:

Derived from the rib section of beef, the Tomahawk steak is a bone-in ribeye with an elongated bone left intact, resembling the handle of a tomahawk axe. This unique presentation is not mere showmanship; the bone enhances flavor and helps retain moisture during cooking. The marbling and tenderness of the ribeye meat further elevate the eating experience, making it a favorite among steak enthusiasts.

Preparing for Grilling:

To maximize your Tomahawk steak’s potential on the grill, follow a few key steps. First, let the steak come to room temperature before cooking to ensure even cooking throughout. Next, generously season with kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper or your preferred steak rub. For an extra burst of flavor, consider marinating overnight in a mixture of olive oil, garlic, rosemary, and Worcestershire sauce.

Grilling Perfection:

Achieving that perfect medium-rare or your desired doneness requires attention to detail. Begin by preheating your grill to high heat (around 450°F). Sear the steak directly over the flames for approximately 2-3 minutes per side, creating beautiful grill marks and sealing in the juices.

Then, move the steak to indirect heat and continue grilling until it reaches your desired internal temperature—around 130°F for medium-rare.

Pro Tips:

  • Invest in a reliable meat thermometer to ensure accurate cooking times.
  • Allow the steak to rest for at least 10 minutes before slicing, enabling the juices to redistribute.
  • Enhance flavor by adding a knob of herb butter or a drizzle of balsamic reduction over the steak during the resting period.
  • Pair your Tomahawk steak with grilled vegetables or a loaded baked potato for a complete and satisfying meal.

Why Most Experts Don’t Recommend Flipping the Tomahawk Steak While Smoking

Imagine this: you’re basking in the warm embrace of a summer breeze, the air filled with the mouthwatering scent of smoky goodness. Your eyes are drawn to a magnificent Tomahawk steak sizzling on the grill, its tantalizing aroma making your taste buds dance with anticipation. But wait, should you flip it? While flipping steaks may be second nature to some grill masters, most experts strongly advise against it when it comes to the mighty Tomahawk.

When smoking a Tomahawk steak, the goal is to cook it slowly and evenly, allowing it to absorb the rich flavors of the wood smoke. Flipping the steak during this process can disrupt the cooking process and wreak havoc on the final outcome in several ways.

Firstly, maintaining a consistent temperature is paramount in achieving that perfect medium-rare doneness. Flipping the steak introduces temperature fluctuations, resulting in uneven cooking. The bone on the Tomahawk steak acts as a natural heat shield, efficiently distributing heat throughout the meat. By flipping the steak, you expose the meat to direct heat, potentially leading to overcooking or uneven doneness.

Moreover, let us not forget about a silent hero in this culinary saga – the fat cap. The fat cap on a Tomahawk steak serves as a glorious shield, protecting the meat from drying out during smoking. Flipping the steak can disrupt this protective barrier, leaving you with a drier end product. The fat also imparts flavor and succulence to the meat as it renders down during cooking, making preserving that layer of fat essential for an unforgettable dining experience.

To achieve gastronomic nirvana while smoking a Tomahawk steak, experts recommend utilizing indirect heat. This means placing the meat away from direct flames or heat sources, allowing for slow and even cooking without any need for flipping. The bone and fat cap work in unison to ensure a mouthwatering, tender, and juicy steak that will leave your taste buds begging for more.

Now, it’s worth noting that some experts argue that flipping the Tomahawk steak once during the smoking process can help achieve an even crust and vibrant color on both sides. If you find yourself tempted to flip, do so with caution and swiftness to minimize heat loss and maintain consistent temperatures. However, let us remember that this is a matter of personal preference and experimentation.

How Flipping Can Disrupt the Cooking Process and Reduce Flavor and Tenderness

Imagine the perfect summer day, with the tantalizing smell of a Tomahawk steak cooking on the grill. But wait, should you flip it? In this article, we will explore how flipping can disrupt the cooking process and potentially reduce flavor and tenderness when grilling a Tomahawk steak.

The Science Behind Flipping:

  • Flipping refers to turning the steak over during cooking.
  • It disrupts the even distribution of heat on the steak’s surface.
  • Flipping exposes one side to direct heat while the other side that was cooking on the grates is now facing downwards.

Flavor and Tenderness Impact:

  • Flipping interrupts the formation of a flavorful crust on the steak’s surface.
  • The Maillard reaction, responsible for a browned and flavorful crust, is disrupted by flipping.
  • An even crust cannot form on both sides of the steak.
  • Juices from the steak are released onto grill grates when flipping, causing moisture loss and potential dryness.

Preserving Flavor and Tenderness:

  • For long cooking cuts like Tomahawk steaks, minimizing flipping is recommended.
  • The bone acts as a natural shield, distributing heat evenly throughout the meat.
  • The fat cap on a Tomahawk steak serves as a protective barrier, adding flavor and succulence while preventing drying out during smoking.

The Risk of Flare-Ups When Flipping the Steak

Flipping a Tomahawk steak while smoking it can be an exhilarating culinary adventure, but it’s not without its risks. The sizzling fat and intense heat can create a perfect storm for flare-ups that might turn your carefully prepared masterpiece into a charred disaster. However, with the right techniques and precautions, you can minimize the chances of these fiery outbursts and ensure a perfectly cooked, mouthwatering piece of meat.

One of the main risks associated with flipping a Tomahawk steak is the potential for flare-ups. These steaks boast a high fat content, which means that as they cook, the fat drips onto the hot coals or flames below. This can lead to sudden bursts of fire that not only pose a safety hazard but also result in uneven cooking and charred spots on the steak. And let’s be honest, no one wants to sink their teeth into a piece of meat that tastes like charcoal.

To minimize the risk of flare-ups, it’s crucial to trim excess fat from the steak before smoking. Grab a sharp knife and carefully remove any visible fat around the edges of the steak. By doing this simple step, you’ll prevent excessive dripping and significantly reduce the chances of flare-ups spoiling your grilling experience.

Another effective way to minimize flare-ups is by using indirect heat while smoking. Create a two-zone fire in your smoker: one side with the hot coals or flames and the other side empty. This setup ensures that the Tomahawk steak is not in direct contact with the heat source, allowing it to cook evenly without being exposed to excessive flames.

Now, when it comes time to flip the steak, arm yourself with long tongs or a spatula with a long handle. This will help you maintain a safe distance from the flames and avoid any accidental contact with the scorching heat. Remember, this isn’t a game of hot potato; you want to savor the smoky goodness without any singed eyebrows.

While flipping is essential to achieve an even sear, it’s crucial to resist the urge to flip the steak more than once during the smoking process. Each time you turn that luscious piece of meat, more fat drips onto the heat source, increasing the risk of flare-ups. So be patient, resist temptation, and flip with purpose.

In the unfortunate event that a flare-up does occur, don’t panic. Close the lid of your smoker immediately to smother the flames and reduce oxygen flow. By taking swift action, you’ll help extinguish the fire quickly and minimize any damage to your precious steak.

Always remember to prioritize safety when smoking and grilling. Keep a fire extinguisher or a bucket of water nearby in case of emergencies, and ensure that the area around your smoker is clear of any flammable materials. After all, there’s nothing worse than having your culinary escapades turn into a full-blown backyard inferno.

Pros of Flipping the Tomahawk Steak While Smoking

It’s time to elevate your smoking game and discover the pros of flipping a Tomahawk steak while smoking. By mastering this technique, you’ll unlock a mouthwatering result that will make your taste buds dance with joy.

So, grab your apron and prepare to embark on a journey of flavor and perfection.

Achieve Even Cooking and Balanced Flavor:

Flipping your Tomahawk steak while smoking ensures even cooking from edge to edge. By giving equal exposure to both sides, you eliminate the dreaded scenario of one side being overcooked while the other remains underdone. Each succulent bite will be bursting with a beautifully balanced flavor that will leave you craving more.

Enhance Crust Development:

The art of flipping allows for a more uniform crust on both sides of the steak. Picture a tantalizing sear that adds visual appeal and enhances the overall texture of your Tomahawk. That perfect golden-brown crust seals in all those delicious juices, offering an irresistible combination of flavors and textures that will make your guests swoon.

Unlock Juicier and More Flavorful Outcomes:

Fat is key to flavor and juiciness, and flipping your Tomahawk steak helps render the fat more evenly. As it melts away, it bastes the meat, infusing it with its rich flavors. The result? A juicy, succulent steak that will have everyone at your grill begging for seconds. Your taste buds won’t know what hit them.

Prevent Fire, Embrace Perfection:

Flipping your Tomahawk steak acts as a preventative measure against flare-ups or charring. By continuously rotating the steak, you reduce the risk of exposing one side to direct heat for too long. Bid farewell to unappealing charred bits, and say hello to a perfectly cooked masterpiece that will impress even the most discerning palates.

Flavor Infusion and Basting Opportunity:

When you flip your Tomahawk steak while smoking, you create an excellent opportunity to baste it with marinades or sauces. This ensures that both sides are coated and infused with the delightful flavors you’ve meticulously crafted. Each mouthwatering bite will be a harmonious blend of smokiness and your chosen seasonings, leaving a lasting impression on your guests.

Accurately Assess Doneness:

Flipping your Tomahawk steak allows for accurate doneness assessment. Utilize a meat thermometer or employ the touch test technique to achieve your desired level of doneness without any guesswork. Bid farewell to overcooked or undercooked steaks and welcome a perfectly cooked masterpiece that will make you the grilling hero among your friends and family.

Tips for Flipping the Tomahawk Steak Safely

Flipping the steak while smoking is a crucial step to ensure even cooking and amazing flavor. In this article, we will share some tips on how to safely flip the Tomahawk steak while smoking. So, grab your tongs and get ready to learn.

Choose the Right Tools:

To flip your Tomahawk steak safely, you need the right tools. Use a sturdy pair of long-handled tongs or a spatula with a wide surface area. These tools will help you grip the steak without getting too close to the heat source.

Wait for the Perfect Moment:

Patience is key when flipping your Tomahawk steak. Wait until the first side develops a nice crust or char, which usually takes around 5 to 10 minutes. This ensures that the meat is seared properly before flipping.

Check the Internal Temperature:

Before flipping, check the internal temperature of your steak using an instant-read thermometer. Aim for around 115°F for medium-rare or 120°F for medium doneness. This helps you determine how much longer the steak needs to cook before flipping.

Gently and Confidently Flip:

When it’s time to flip, do it gently and confidently. Avoid any sudden movements or jerking motions that could cause the steak to fall apart or slip through your tongs. A smooth and controlled flip is the secret to success.

Monitor Internal Temperature:

After flipping, keep an eye on the internal temperature of your steak regularly. This helps you know when it reaches your desired level of doneness. Remember, the temperature continues to rise as the steak rests, so take it out a few degrees below your target temperature.

Rest and Slice:

Once your Tomahawk steak reaches the desired doneness, carefully remove it from the smoker and let it rest for at least 10 minutes. This allows the juices to redistribute, resulting in a more tender and flavorful steak. When slicing, use a sharp knife and cut against the grain for maximum tenderness.

v6lwpupzcrA” >


In conclusion, the age-old question of whether to flip a Tomahawk steak while smoking has ignited fiery debates among grill masters. While some staunchly oppose any flipping, the majority of experts advocate for leaving the sizzling slab untouched throughout the smoking process.

Flipping this majestic cut can disrupt the delicate dance of cooking and result in an unsavory unevenness. The bone that juts out from the Tomahawk steak acts as a natural shield, gracefully diffusing heat and ensuring an even distribution throughout its succulent flesh. But when flipped, one side is thrust into direct heat, risking overcooking or a haphazard doneness that leaves taste buds disappointed.

Moreover, flipping rudely interrupts the formation of a tantalizing crust on the steak’s surface. The magical Maillard reaction, responsible for conjuring up that delectably browned and flavorful exterior, is abruptly halted mid-transformation when the steak takes an ill-advised somersault. This culinary crime not only compromises flavor but also jeopardizes tenderness.

And let us not forget about those treacherous flare-ups lurking in the shadows of dripping fat. Flipping heightens this perilous risk, turning your grilling escapade into a dangerous dance with flames. To tame this inferno, it is crucial to trim excess fat before smoking and employ indirect heat like a wise chef.

However, amidst these cautionary tales lie potential benefits to flipping. It can be a secret weapon in your quest for uniform cooking and harmonious flavors that permeate every fiber of your precious steak. By deftly turning it over, you ensure that both sides partake in an equal journey towards crust development perfection. Additionally, flipping aids in rendering fat evenly, unlocking juiciness and unleashing flavors that will have taste buds singing with joy.

Ultimately, whether you choose to flip or not to flip your Tomahawk steak while smoking lies within your realm of personal preference and culinary experimentation. Consider these factors carefully, for they hold the key to unlocking your desired outcome.

Scroll to Top