Do I season both sides of brisket?

Do you crave that succulent, smoky flavor of a perfectly cooked brisket? That slow-cooked cut of beef that melts in your mouth and leaves you wanting more? If so, then you know that seasoning is key when it comes to making the best brisket. But the question remains: should you season both sides of the brisket or just the top?

Some BBQ experts suggest only seasoning the top side while others swear by coating both sides evenly. So, which method should you follow? Well, it depends on how you plan to cook your brisket. If smoking is your preferred method, then seasoning both sides will ensure that every morsel is infused with flavor. However, if grilling or baking is your choice, then seasoning just the top side may be sufficient.

But wait. Before you start sprinkling on any old rub, keep in mind that different seasonings have different effects on meat. Rubs with sugar or salt should be used sparingly to avoid overpowering the natural flavors of the meat. On the other hand, spicy rubs can be applied more liberally for an extra kick.

In this blog post, we’ll delve into all aspects of seasoning your brisket – from choosing the right blend of spices to applying them correctly – so that you can elevate your BBQ game and create a mouth-watering masterpiece every time.


The Pros of Seasoning Both Sides of the Brisket

Brisket, the king of barbecue meats, is often the centerpiece of any backyard cookout. And whether you’re a seasoned pitmaster or a novice griller, there’s one question that always comes up: should you season both sides of the brisket? Well, as an expert on the topic, I can confidently say that there are several pros to seasoning both sides of the meat.

First and foremost, seasoning both sides ensures that every bite of the brisket is packed with flavor. When you only season one side, you risk leaving the other side bland and unseasoned. But by seasoning both sides, you guarantee a more even distribution of flavor throughout the meat. And who doesn’t love a juicy and flavorful brisket?

But it’s not just about taste. Seasoning both sides also helps to create an even crust on the brisket, which is key to achieving that perfect barbecue texture. When seasoning is only applied to one side, that side may end up with a thicker crust than the other, resulting in an uneven texture and taste. But by seasoning both sides, you can achieve a more uniform crust that enhances the overall eating experience.

Moreover, seasoning both sides can help to tenderize the meat. Many seasoning blends contain salt and other ingredients that work to break down tough muscle fibers and make the meat more tender. By applying these seasonings to both sides of the brisket, you give them more time to penetrate the meat and work their magic. And who doesn’t love a tender and juicy brisket?

Lastly, seasoning both sides can simply make for a more visually appealing dish. A well-seasoned brisket with an even crust on both sides can look incredibly appetizing and impressive when served up on a platter. And let’s face it, we eat with our eyes too.

The Cons of Seasoning Both Sides of the Brisket

The question of whether to season both sides of a brisket is a common one in the world of barbecue. While some argue that seasoning both sides can enhance the flavor, there are also some potential cons to consider.

Perhaps the most significant downside to seasoning both sides of the brisket is the risk of over-seasoning. Too much seasoning can overpower the natural taste of the meat, making it difficult to appreciate its unique flavor. Moreover, if you’re using a rub with a high salt content, it can draw out moisture from the meat, leaving it dry and tough.

Another issue with seasoning both sides is that it can create a crust that’s too thick. Not only is this unappetizing, but it can also detract from the overall enjoyment of the dish. Additionally, if you plan on smoking your brisket, seasoning both sides can cause the rub to burn, resulting in an unpleasant taste.

Finally, seasoning both sides of your brisket can be wasteful. By coating both sides with seasoning, you’re using more than necessary and potentially wasting ingredients. This not only increases the cost of your meal unnecessarily but also contributes to food waste.

So what’s the solution? It ultimately comes down to personal preference and experimentation. Start by seasoning only one side of your brisket and see how it turns out. If you feel like it needs more flavor, add seasoning to the other side as well. Remember, less is often more when it comes to seasoning your meat.

Tips for Seasoning Both Sides of the Brisket

If you’re looking to elevate your brisket game, then seasoning both sides of the meat is a must. It ensures that every bite is packed with flavor and no bland spots are left behind. Here are five tips for seasoning both sides of the brisket to perfection.

Generously Coat Both Sides

Don’t be shy with the seasoning. Use a generous amount on both sides of the meat, including the edges and corners. This helps to ensure that the flavor permeates throughout the meat and creates a well-balanced taste.

Give It Time

Patience is key when it comes to seasoning a brisket. Allow at least 24 hours for the seasoning to penetrate the meat fully. This will enhance its flavor and provide an even taste.

Combine Dry Rub and Liquid Marinade

A combination of dry rub and liquid marinade can take your brisket to the next level. Dry rubs add texture and flavor to the surface of the meat, while marinades tenderize and infuse flavor into the meat.

Let It Rest

Letting your seasoned brisket rest at room temperature for at least 30 minutes before cooking is essential. This allows the flavors to meld together and results in a juicy, tender final product.

Monitor Temperature Closely

When grilling or smoking your brisket, it’s crucial to monitor the temperature closely. This ensures that your brisket cooks evenly and doesn’t dry out. Use a thermometer to check the internal temperature regularly.

The Benefits of Only Seasoning One Side of the Brisket

While many swear by seasoning both sides, there are some serious benefits to only seasoning one side of the brisket.

Firstly, seasoning only one side will ensure a more even cook, preventing one side from being overly charred while the other remains under-seasoned. This means that you’ll get a perfectly cooked brisket that’s bursting with flavor in every bite.

But that’s not all – only seasoning one side of the brisket also helps create a better bark. A good bark is essential to any delicious brisket, and by seasoning only one side, you allow for better moisture distribution and seasoning absorption. This leads to a mouthwatering bark that will have your taste buds dancing.

And let’s not forget about the cost savings. By only using spices on one side, you can make your spices last longer and save money in the long run. This is great news for those who are passionate about cooking but also conscious about their budget.

Do I season both sides of brisket-2

The Drawbacks to Only Seasoning One Side of the Brisket

If so, then you know that the seasoning is one of the most important parts of the cooking process. However, there’s a debate among brisket lovers about whether to season one side or both sides of the meat. While seasoning only one side may seem like an easy shortcut, it actually comes with some potential drawbacks that could ruin your meal.

One major issue with only seasoning one side of the brisket is that it can create an uneven flavor profile. The seasoned side will have a more intense flavor, while the unseasoned side may taste bland by comparison. This can be especially disappointing if you’re serving guests or looking forward to a perfectly balanced bite. To avoid this problem, it’s essential to season both sides of the brisket evenly.

In addition to uneven flavor, only seasoning one side can also lead to uneven cooking. The side with the seasoning will absorb more heat and cook faster than the unseasoned side, which can result in overcooked and dry meat on one side while the other is still undercooked and tough. This inconsistency can be frustrating and make for an unpleasant dining experience.

Another drawback of only seasoning one side of the brisket is that it can affect the development of the bark or crust on the meat. The seasoning helps create a flavorful crust on the surface of the meat, but if only one side is seasoned, it may not develop as evenly or as well. The bark is one of the most delicious parts of a perfectly cooked brisket, and missing out on it due to uneven seasoning would be a real shame.

Tips for Only Seasoning One Side of the Brisket

You can now season just one side with ease and still achieve a delicious outcome. Here are some tips to help you season your brisket perfectly.

Firstly, choose the right side of the brisket to season. The fat cap side is usually the bottom of the brisket, and it’s recommended to leave it untouched. Instead, season the top or meaty side of the brisket. This will ensure that the flavors penetrate deeply into the meat during cooking.

Secondly, don’t be shy with your seasoning. Use a generous amount of seasoning on the top side of your brisket to ensure even coating. You can use any seasoning blend of your choice, but a popular option is a simple mixture of kosher salt, black pepper, and garlic powder. Sprinkle the seasoning onto the meat and then pat it down with your hands to ensure that it sticks.

Thirdly, let the seasoning sit on the meat for at least an hour before cooking. This will allow enough time for the flavors to be absorbed into the meat properly. If you have time, you can even let it sit overnight in the fridge for even more flavor. This step is crucial in ensuring that every bite is packed with flavor.

Fourthly, when placing the brisket on the grill or smoker, ensure that you place it seasoned side up. This will allow for maximum flavor infusion into the meat while cooking. Plus, it will give you a beautiful crust on top of your brisket.

Lastly, cook your brisket low and slow to ensure that it’s tender and juicy. It’s essential to resist the urge to turn up the heat as this can result in a dry and tough brisket. By following these tips, you can successfully season only one side of your brisket and still enjoy a delicious meal.

S95WTkNaLAM” >


In conclusion, seasoning your brisket is a crucial step in achieving the perfect flavor. The decision to season both sides or just one should be made with a clear understanding of the potential benefits and drawbacks of each method.

Seasoning both sides of your brisket ensures an even distribution of flavors, creates a mouth-watering crust, and can even tenderize the meat. However, over-seasoning and creating a too-thick crust are possible pitfalls to avoid.

On the other hand, only seasoning one side can result in more consistent cooking and better bark development. Additionally, using less seasoning on just one side can save you money on spices. However, uneven flavor distribution and inconsistent cooking times are possible drawbacks.

To achieve the best results when seasoning your brisket, use generous amounts of seasoning on the chosen side(s), give it time to absorb flavors before cooking, monitor temperature closely during cooking, and let it rest before serving. Ultimately, whether you choose to season both sides or just one comes down to personal preference and experimentation.

Scroll to Top