Are steaks better on a grill or griddle?

The season of sunshine, pool parties, and most importantly, grilling. But what if we told you that your trusty grill might not be the best way to cook up a juicy steak? Enter the griddle – the flat-topped hero that just might give your grill a run for its money.

Sure, grilling over an open flame has its appeal. The smoky flavor and those picturesque grill marks are hard to resist. But have you ever tried cooking a steak on a hot griddle? The result is a crispy crust with a moist and juicy interior that will make your taste buds dance.

In this post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each method so you can decide which one suits your steak preferences best. We’ll get into the nitty-gritty of searing science and talk about which cuts of meat work best on each surface. Trust us – you might be surprised at which method comes out on top.

So whether you’re a seasoned grill master or a newbie griddle guru, keep reading to find out if your go-to cooking method is truly the best way to cook up that perfect steak.


What is Grilling?

Grilling is more than just a cooking technique. It is a social activity that brings people together over great food. Whether you prefer gas, charcoal, or electric grills, the high heat from the flames sears the surface of the meat, creating a flavorful crust while keeping the inside juicy and tender. But what makes grilling so special, and why do people swear by this cooking method?

Firstly, one of the key advantages of grilling is the smoky flavor it imparts to the food being cooked. This unique taste comes from the combination of flames, smoke, and meat juices that create a mouth-watering aroma that can be hard to resist. The smoky flavor adds depth and complexity to the taste, making it a popular choice for meat lovers around the world.

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-2

Secondly, grilling is a healthy cooking method compared to frying or sautĂ©ing as it allows excess fat to drip away from the food, reducing calorie intake while preserving the flavor. It’s a great way to cook lean meats like chicken breasts or fish fillets without adding extra oil or butter.

Thirdly, grilling is not just about cooking food; it’s also an enjoyable activity that can bring people closer together. Grilling outdoors on a beautiful day with friends and family is an excellent way to relax, unwind, and enjoy good food and company. It’s a chance to disconnect from technology and connect with the people around us.

When it comes to steaks, grilling is often the preferred method for many meat lovers. The high heat can quickly sear the outside while keeping the inside juicy and tender. However, there is an ongoing debate on whether steaks are better grilled or cooked on a griddle. Both methods have their pros and cons, but ultimately, it depends on personal preference and the type of steak being cooked.

For thicker cuts like ribeye or sirloin, grilling may be the better option as the high heat can quickly sear the outside while keeping the inside juicy and tender. However, for thinner cuts like flank or skirt steak, cooking on a griddle may be preferable as it allows for an even cook without worrying about burning or overcooking.

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-3

Pros of Grilling Steaks

Firstly, grilling imparts a unique smoky flavor to steaks that cannot be replicated with any other cooking method. This flavor comes from the heat of the grill and the smoke created by the dripping fat from the meat. It adds depth and complexity to the taste that is simply irresistible.

But that’s not all. Grilling also allows for greater control over the temperature and cooking time of the steak. With a gas or charcoal grill, you can adjust the heat to get a perfect sear on the outside while keeping the inside juicy and tender. This means you can cook your steak exactly how you like it, every time.

Grilling is also versatile and can accommodate different types of steaks. You can cook thicker cuts like ribeyes or thinner cuts like sirloin steaks all on the same grill, adjusting the cooking time and temperature accordingly. This means you can please everyone’s palate without needing multiple cooking methods.

Another great benefit of grilling steaks is the ability to cook larger quantities at once. This makes it an ideal choice for hosting gatherings or feeding a large family. And let’s face it, nothing beats a good BBQ with friends and family. The social atmosphere created by grilling is second to none, making it a classic American pastime that creates lasting memories.

Finally, let’s not forget that grilling is an outdoor activity that can be enjoyed in warm weather. It’s an opportunity to get outside, breathe in fresh air, and enjoy some sunshine while preparing delicious food.

Cons of Grilling Steaks

Grilling steaks on a hot summer day is a quintessential American activity, but it’s important to know the cons of this cooking method. While grilling can create delicious, smoky flavors, there are some drawbacks to consider before starting up the grill.

The first potential issue with grilling steaks is uneven cooking. Depending on the thickness of the steak and the temperature of the grill, you may end up with an overcooked exterior and a raw interior. This can create a tough and chewy texture that is unappetizing.

Another con of grilling is controlling the temperature. It’s easy to burn the outside of your steak if the grill is too hot or leave it undercooked if it’s not hot enough. It can take some practice to get your grill to just the right temperature to create a perfectly cooked steak.

If you’re using charcoal or wood chips to grill your steak, you’ll also have to deal with ash and smoke. This can create a mess and even leave a strong odor on your clothes and nearby surfaces. It’s important to keep this in mind when planning your grilling location and attire.

Finally, grilling requires skill and attention. You need to know when to flip your steak and how long to cook it for. Without proper attention, you risk creating a dry and flavorless piece of meat.

What is Cooking on a Griddle?

Cooking on a griddle may just be the answer you’ve been searching for. As an expert in this area, let me tell you that cooking on a griddle is a game-changer in the kitchen.

Firstly, let’s discuss what a griddle is. It’s a flat cooking surface typically made of cast iron, stainless steel, or aluminum. The surface is heated evenly using propane or natural gas, or it can be electrically powered. This means that you can cook multiple items at once without worrying about some parts being undercooked while others are overcooked. Moreover, the flat surface allows for better contact between the food and heat source, resulting in faster cooking times.

One of the most significant advantages of cooking on a griddle is how easy it is to clean up. Most griddles have a non-stick surface that makes it easy to wipe down with a damp cloth or sponge after use. Say goodbye to scrubbing off tough grease stains from your grill.

When it comes to cooking steaks on a griddle, there are a few things to keep in mind. While you may not get the same char and grill marks as you would on a traditional grill, don’t let that discourage you. You can still achieve a delicious sear and crust by preheating the griddle before adding your steaks and seasoning them with salt and pepper. Cook them for 2-3 minutes per side for medium-rare, and voila. You’ll have perfectly cooked steaks with minimal effort.

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-4

Cooking on a griddle offers other advantages too. Here are a few:

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-5

  • Large cooking surface: The size of a typical griddle provides ample space to cook multiple items at once. For example, think pancakes, bacon, and eggs in one go.
  • Even heating: The surface is heated evenly, which means that you won’t have to worry about hot spots or uneven cooking.
  • Versatility: A griddle can be used for cooking more than just steaks. You can cook burgers, vegetables, seafood, and even grilled cheese sandwiches on it.

Pros of Cooking on a Griddle

Well, look no further than the mighty griddle. As a culinary expert, I can attest that cooking on a griddle has numerous pros that are worth exploring, especially when it comes to steaks.

Firstly, a griddle provides a consistent heat source that distributes evenly across its surface. Unlike a grill, which may have hot and cold spots, this ensures your steak cooks evenly throughout for a more succulent and flavorsome finished product.

Moreover, using a griddle requires less oil or none at all when compared to grilling. Since the surface is naturally non-stick, you can cook your steak with minimal oil. This doesn’t just create healthier meals but also allows the meat’s natural flavors to shine through without being masked by excess oil.

Furthermore, cooking on a griddle enables quick and effective searing of your steak. The high heat of the griddle guarantees that your steak develops a crisp crust while retaining its juiciness and tenderness.

Lastly, using a griddle provides more control over the cooking process. Unlike grilling outdoors, which can be affected by weather conditions such as wind and rain, cooking indoors on a griddle allows you to control the temperature and cooking conditions more precisely for consistent results every time.

Cons of Cooking on a Griddle

While there are certainly some benefits to this method, it’s also important to consider the potential drawbacks before diving in. As an expert in this topic, I’ve done extensive research and compiled a comprehensive list of the main cons associated with cooking on a griddle.

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-6

One major downside of using a griddle is that it can be difficult to achieve the same level of char and smoky flavor that you would get from a grill. Griddles typically don’t reach the high temperatures that grills do, and they lack the open flames that create that signature grilled taste. If you’re someone who loves that smoky flavor, you may find the results from a griddle disappointing.

Another potential issue with griddles is controlling the temperature. While you have control over the heat source, griddles provide a flat, even surface that can be challenging to adjust. This can make it harder to achieve the perfect level of doneness for your steak, especially if you prefer yours cooked to a specific temperature.

Additionally, cooking on a griddle can be messier than using a grill. All the juices and fats from the meat accumulate on the flat surface, resulting in smoke and splattering. This can be inconvenient and even dangerous if you’re not careful. Plus, cleaning up a greasy griddle can be quite a chore compared to simply brushing down a grill grate.

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-7

Finally, some people simply prefer the outdoor experience of grilling over cooking indoors on a griddle. Grilling is often associated with summertime cookouts, backyard parties, and other social events that bring people together. Cooking on a griddle just doesn’t have that same sense of community and connection for many people.

Choosing the Right Method for Different Types of Steaks

When it comes to cooking steaks, selecting the right method can be the difference between a delicious meal and a disappointing one. Grilling and griddling are two popular methods, but how do you know which one is best for your steak? Here are some factors to consider:

Thickness of the Steak:

The thickness of the steak is a critical factor in determining the cooking method. Grilling is ideal for thicker cuts like ribeye or sirloin as the high heat sears the outside while keeping the inside juicy and tender. In contrast, thinner cuts like flank or skirt steak may cook too quickly on the grill, making them tough. A griddle may be a better option for these cuts as it allows for more control over the cooking temperature and can result in a more tender steak.

Fat Content:

The fat content of the steak also plays a role in choosing the cooking method. A leaner cut like filet mignon may not benefit from grilling’s high heat as much as a fattier cut like strip or ribeye. The fat helps keep the steak juicy and flavorful when cooked on a grill, but on a griddle, it may result in a greasy texture.

Personal Preference:

Are steaks better on a grill or griddle-8

Personal preference is an essential factor to consider when choosing between grilling and griddling. Grilling gives steaks that classic smoky flavor that many people love, but others prefer the precise temperature control that a griddle provides. Experimenting with both methods is crucial to find what works best for you.

Char Marks:

If you’re a fan of those signature char marks on your steak, then grilling is your go-to method. The flames provide heat from all sides, creating those beautiful grill marks on the surface of the steak. A griddle doesn’t produce char marks, but it does provide even heat distribution resulting in perfectly cooked meat every time.

Indoor vs. Outdoor Cooking:

Grilling is an outdoor activity, and not everyone has access to an outdoor grill. A griddle can be used indoors, making it a more convenient option for those who want to cook steak year-round or in colder climates.

LahAOtR_5BI” >


In conclusion, the age-old debate of whether steaks are better grilled or cooked on a griddle remains unresolved. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages, making it challenging to determine which one is superior. Grilling imparts that classic smoky flavor that we all love, but controlling temperature can be tricky, and uneven cooking may occur. Conversely, cooking on a griddle provides even heat distribution resulting in perfectly cooked meat every time but lacks the signature grill marks and smoky flavor.

When deciding between grilling and griddling, several factors come into play. The thickness of the steak, fat content, personal preference, char marks, and indoor vs. outdoor cooking are all crucial considerations.

Ultimately, there is no definitive answer when it comes to choosing between grilling and griddling. It depends entirely on individual preferences and circumstances. Whether you’re an experienced grill master or a novice griddle guru, experimenting with both methods is crucial to find what works best for you.

So whether you decide to fire up your grill or heat up your griddle, remember that summertime is all about enjoying good food with friends and family.

Scroll to Top